Even loyal bishops and insiders are dismayed by apparent inaction on McCarrick

To the surprise of many Catholic commentators, Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York has emerged as a leading voice in the calls for a full Vatican inquiry into the decades-long cover-up of Theodore McCarrick’s sexual misconduct. A consummate insider well regarded by three consecutive popes, Dolan has nevertheless told the press that he is growing “impatient” waiting for an apostolic visitation – that is, a formal investigation ordered by the Pope. For that reason, he has appointed a former federal judge, Barbara Jones, to review his archdiocese’s protocols relating to sexual abuse.

Cardinal Dolan was joined in his call for papal intervention by a prominent layman with close ties to the Archdiocese of Washington. John Carr, director of Georgetown University’s Initiative for Catholic Social Thought and Public Life, told a panel that the Holy Father “has been too slow to understand and act on the moral and spiritual consequences of abuse”. Carr went on to say that the “isolation, institutional protection and lack of connection to anguish of survivors and their families have often led to a lack of empathy, urgency and action” among Church leaders.

Carr’s appeal is especially striking given his links to several once-powerful bishops. He worked for the US Conference of Catholic Bishops on Capitol Hill for 20 years, where he advised Cardinal Bernard Law, the late Archbishop of Boston and the focus of the Boston Globe’s “Spotlight” investigation, which sparked the abuse crisis of the early 2000s.

He also worked closely with McCarrick, whom he called a “friend … and a great supporter of my work”. More recently, he has collaborated with McCarrick’s successor, the embattled Cardinal Donald Wuerl. Carr called Wuerl a friend, too, and applauded his request that Francis accept his resignation. “Defending past choices is no substitute for owning and personally apologising for past actions that harmed the vulnerable,” said Carr.

Carr might not be a household name the way Dolan is, but his credentials as an insider are impressive. It is one thing for pundits who have been consistently critical of Francis to condemn the Holy Father’s inaction – indeed, Carr made a point of warning against “those who seem to use the suffering of survivors to settle scores or to advance their own ideological agendas or their opposition to Pope Francis”. But for men distinguished for their loyalty to the Holy See to criticise a Pope in public demonstrates how profoundly this crisis is changing the Church. Dolan and Carr’s “impatience” is no doubt exacerbated by enormous pressure from the laity, who want their bishops to adopt a “full mobilisation” mentality. There can be no business as usual, they say, until McCarrick’s enablers are brought to justice and abusers are purged from the clergy.

​How to continue reading…

This article appears in the Catholic Herald magazine - to read it in full subscribe to our digital edition from just 30p a week

The Catholic Herald is your essential weekly guide to the Catholic world; latest news, incisive opinion, expert analysis and spiritual reflection